Ok I feel like I have to weigh in on the Colton Orr hit on Matt Cullen during the New York Rangers vs Hurricanes game. Opinions are very mixed on whether it was a dirty or legal hit. It ranges from people wanting him suspended to many fans and writers even saying he was jobbed on the 5 minute interference and game misconduct call.
So here is my take, granted I am a Rangers fan. Orr saw Cullen well ahead of the play, in fact he actually lowered his body and took his hand off his stick well ahead of impact. While his right arm did come off the stick and follow thru he did not lead with his elbow nor strike Cullen with it. It looked more like his right glove hit Cullen in addition to Orr's face hitting Cullen's visor (see photo). Cullen clearly never saw Orr coming as he was looking for the puck which was at his feet until right before impact.
So here are some of the I always ask when a hit is questionable:
Was the puck there? Although Cullen did not have possession of the puck at time of impact, he had just lost it so I consider it clean from that perspective.
Was there a deliberate blow to the head? I would say no, Colton did not use his stick, elbow or forearm in a deliberate manner. Him taking his right hand off the stick does cloud the argument. However based on photos and interviews afterward Orr's face took the brunt of Cullen's visor. He was cut during impact, not by his fight afterward.
Was there intent to injure? This is a trickier question. Orr clearly lined Cullen up ahead of time and did not collide with him ala the Knuble/Shanny hit (like some writers have suggested). Sorry, I watched the tape 20 times and I see Colton lowering his body, taking his hand off the stick and getting ready for impact. However based on Colton's history, he has not been a dirty checker, in fact he rarely ever hits open ice, although that is probably due to his inability skate fast enough to hit open ice. He also was a teammate of Cullen's so I doubt there was intent to injure. Since he did not head hunt I think this is still a legal hit in the NHL, not sure it seems to change day to day.
The five minute and game misconduct interference call was definitely influenced by the severity of the collision and possible retribution the refs feared from HQ. Several articles have written how Shanahan spoke to an official on the ice and was under the impression
there was no penalty. Only to find out moments later that it was 5 and a game. Hmm, none of the refs had their arm up and then suddenly after a huddle they come up with the call. I guess they erred on the side of caution and fear of being punished by the league. Its going to be very interesting to see if Colin Campbell issues a suspension on this one. Keep in mind he has historically been very heavy handed when sentencing player from his former team.
Here's hoping to full and speedy recovery to Matt Cullen. Wish you were still centering the 3rd line.